Prompted by @tomburke999 on Twitter, I’ve worked out the cost per passenger of the New Bus compared to a notional* 87-passenger £300k hybrid:
- 8 pre-production buses of 77 capacity – £11m
- 600 production buses of 80 capacity (so far) – £212m
- Total 608 buses at £223m including development costs (which we’re assuming won’t ever be defrayed by sales outside London because, well, they won’t)
- That’s actually £367k per bus, not the £354k calculated purely for the production vehicles
It’s also 8*77 + 600*80 = 48616 passengers, at a cost of £4587 per passenger. Our notional hybrid is 300000/87 = £3448. So that’s a nice round 33% more expensive per passenger, then.
This isn’t just a numbers exercise, though – London’s transport grant is being slashed by George Osborne and the DfT just as Boris is putting TfL’s cash into a bus that costs substantially more to carry people around. That’s going to hurt someone at some point, either through being unable to meet demand for travel as London expands or by continuing massive fare hikes. The Greens have started pointing this out:
The New Bus for London is an expensive vanity project which the next Mayor will abandon as an outdated and polluting waste of money. Londoners’ simply can’t afford the higher fares that will come from paying £37m a year to bus assistants whose only real job is to stop people falling off the rear platform when it is open.
Indeed, what the next Mayor does with them is difficult, there’s no doubt they’re conceptually popular with the public, because the relentless presentation is entirely on the upside and they falsely think they’re getting conductors and an open platform and they’ll operate widely across London. It’s got friends in very high places in TfL (Hendy and Daniels) who are presumably not challenged from below, and certainly not from above. I’ve long thought that when Boris goes TfL will quietly abandon the standing around doing nothing person and use them purely as three door open boarding vehicles (a bit like, er, bendy buses), which will at least offset some of the cost. We sure as hell aren’t going to see our £223m back, and at this rate fares are going to continue rising into 2018/19 as the subsidy reduces year on year. By which time Boris will have sodded off, with any luck, and be busy lying to everyone about his great bus project. That’s partly why it’s important to point all this out now.
* Yes, I know, but if TfL can invent a wholly spurious ‘average’ hybrid to make the NB4L look better on emissions (rather than, say, comparing it to the current evolution of its rivals) I don’t see this as particularly outragous
Contact usSend us an e-mail at staff [at] boriswatch.co.uk
- Deck Staining on Great Boris Lies #8 – Air Quality
- bit.Ly on Great Boris Lies #8 – Air Quality
- Andrew on Roastmaster Round-Up – What A Difference A Year Makes. Oh…
- gagner plus argent on DodgyVisasRUs – Boris’s Ex-Wife And Recently-Appointed Member Of City Hall’s Muslim Engagement Task Force Can “Pull Strings”
- Dave H on “Which idiot in charge decided to buy buses with windows that don’t open?”
- Alexandra Jane Kirby on “Which idiot in charge decided to buy buses with windows that don’t open?”
- Anonymous on Roastmaster Round-Up – What A Difference A Year Makes. Oh…
- Anonymous on Sir Peter Hendy, Commissioner of Transport for London: “It’s not a political issue……”
Tagsagendas BBC BBC London bendy Boris Airport borisport broken promises budget bus buses crime culture cycling earnings environment Gilligan grasp of detail humour incompetence jobs Johnson Administration Ken Livingstone lies Mayor's Question Time olympics police Policy Exchange Press questions Rape Ray Lewis resignation RMT Routemaster salaries Speeches spin strike Stuff On Nonsense team TfL transparency transport tube TV